top of page
LTK Insurance

Real Medicare Offer or Scam? How to Tell During Open Enrollment in Kissimmee, and What a Licensed Agent Can and Can't Do

Writer: Ryan Goulding
Ryan Goulding
Oct 28
7 min read

Open enrollment is a busy season. Medicare Open Enrollment runs October 15 to December 7, and the Marketplace on HealthCare.gov opens November 1.

Federal and Florida officials say fake ads, look-alike websites and pushy calls pick up at this time of year. Here's how to tell a real offer from a scam, what a licensed agent can and can't do, and who to call in Florida, for neighbors in Kissimmee, St. Cloud, Poinciana and across Osceola County.

Does Medicare call you about open enrollment?

Medicare won't call you uninvited to ask for personal information, and it won't call to sell you anything or come to your home. If someone says they're "from Medicare," hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) yourself.

When Medicare may contact you

Per Medicare.gov, Medicare, or someone working for Medicare, may call in a few limited situations, such as returning a call you made or following up on something you started. If you didn't expect the call, hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE.

Protect your Medicare Number like a credit card

Share your Medicare Number only with your doctors, your insurance company or plan (and their licensed agents), or people who work with Medicare, like your State Health Insurance Assistance Program. See Medicare.gov's Your Medicare card page.

Calls About a Medicare "Rebate" Check

In October 2026, Medicare sent a one-time Part B premium rebate to people in Original Medicare Part B. Most got a direct deposit from Social Security, and some got a paper check from the U.S. Treasury. Per CMS and Medicare.gov, Medicare Advantage members, people whose Part B premium is paid by Medicaid, and people who pay an Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA) aren't eligible.

Medicare won't call you asking for your Medicare Number or bank information to send this rebate. If a caller offers to "release" or "process" a rebate for you, hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) yourself to check whether you're eligible. To check on a payment, call Social Security at 1-800-772-1213.

Red flags: how to spot a fake Medicare offer (ads, calls, websites, mail)

Pressure, requests for your numbers before anything is explained, "everyone qualifies" money or benefits, and government-looking logos on a private company's ad are warning signs.

  • A caller says they're "from Medicare" or "Medicare enrollment."

  • Someone asks for your Medicare Number, Social Security number or bank information before explaining anything, or to "update your file."

  • Someone shows up at your home without an appointment you made.

  • You hear "Enroll today or you'll lose your Medicare." That isn't true. Open Enrollment is a choice, not a requirement.

  • An ad says everyone qualifies for extra money, or for "new," "extra" or "unclaimed" benefits, instead of explaining coverage.

  • A website or ad uses Medicare- or government-looking logos, cards or web addresses that don't end in .gov.

  • Anyone asks for a fee to enroll you in a Medicare plan.

These come from a Federal Trade Commission alert, a Florida consumer-protection alert from Operation Senior Shield, and an October 2026 warning from a Central Florida state attorney's office.

Search ads and look-alike sites

The FTC says some paid search ads lead to look-alike pages, and the state attorney's office warns that some fake sites sell plans that don't exist. Type Medicare.gov or HealthCare.gov into your browser yourself. Look for "Ad" or "Sponsored" labels and scroll past them. Real government sites end in .gov.

Online forms

A "learn about new Medicare benefits" form can lead to many sales calls. Before you type your phone number, know who is collecting your information and why. The same state attorney's office says some sites sell phone numbers to "predatory callers."

What a licensed agent can and can't do

Licensed agents and brokers can explain plans and help you enroll. Medicare's rules say they can't call you without permission, come to your home uninvited, charge you a fee, or pressure you.

This table follows Medicare.gov's marketing rules page:

A licensed agent can

A licensed agent can't

Give you plan materials

Call or text you unless you're a plan member or gave permission, or come to your home uninvited

Explain your plan options

Ask for bank or card numbers just to give you a quote, or ask you to pay over the phone or online (the plan sends a bill)

Give you an enrollment form

Charge an enrollment fee, or offer cash, gifts worth more than $15, or meals at no cost to you as an incentive to join

Collect your completed form

Require you to talk to a sales agent to get plan information, or discuss plans you didn't agree to without a separate appointment form

Give you a business card

Steer or pressure you, or have you sign before you're ready

Call you back if you asked them to or gave permission

Sell you non-health products like annuities or life insurance during a Medicare sales pitch

After a meeting, a plan representative may contact you to make sure you understand how the plan works

Talk plans in exam rooms, hospital rooms or at the pharmacy counter, market or enroll at an educational event like a health fair, or use misleading Medicare or CMS logos or cards

Want a second opinion on a call, mailer or ad you got? Bring it to a no-cost Medicare review. There's no cost to you for the review and no obligation to enroll.

Why an agent asks you to agree to an appointment first (Scope of Appointment)

Before a sales appointment, Medicare requires the agent to record which kinds of plans you agreed to talk about. During the appointment, they can discuss only those products, unless you ask for more and agree in a new form.

For in-person appointments, it must be in writing (42 CFR 422.2264). It's not an enrollment, and it doesn't sign you up for anything.

Before an agent talks plan details, they must tell you who they represent

Agents who work with more than one company must tell you how many organizations and products they represent in your area, and point you to Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE for all your options. That's the disclaimer at the bottom of this page.

In plain English: an agent may not offer every plan in your area. You can compare all options on Medicare.gov, at 1-800-MEDICARE, or with Florida SHINE.

How to check that an agent is licensed in Florida

Use the Florida Department of Financial Services Licensee Search. Search the agent's name or license number and check that the license is active.

Per Medicare.gov, agents who sell Medicare plans must be licensed by your state, and plans must tell the state which agents sell their plans. Ask any agent for their full name, license number and National Producer Number (NPN). A real agent will give them. Mine are in the author line at the end of this post.

The Florida Department of Financial Services also notes that a policy sold by an unauthorized agent may not be valid (Insurance Fraud and Scams).

Shopping on HealthCare.gov? The same tricks show up for the Marketplace

Type HealthCare.gov yourself or call 1-800-318-2596. The FTC warns that look-alike sites may sell things that aren't health insurance.

Marketplace open enrollment runs November 1, 2026, to January 15, 2027. Choose a plan by December 15 for coverage that starts January 1 (see HealthCare.gov's dates and deadlines). For help in person, use "Find Local Help" on HealthCare.gov.

Think you were targeted? Who to call in Florida

Pause. Verify. Compare.

  1. Stop. Don't give any numbers, sign anything or pay anything.

  2. Call Medicare yourself. Hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). TTY 1-877-486-2048.

  3. Call Florida SHINE / Senior Medicare Patrol. 1-800-96-ELDER (1-800-963-5337) or FloridaSHINE.org. Counseling is no-cost and unbiased, and SHINE counselors don't sell insurance.

  4. Report it. File a report with the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and with the Florida Attorney General.

  5. Medicare Advantage or drug plan issue? Call Medicare's I-MEDIC line at 1-877-7SAFERX (1-877-772-3379).

  6. Gave out your information? Call the Identity Theft Resource Center at 888-400-5530, and check your Medicare statements for services you didn't get.

What to bring to a review (and what we'll never ask for)

Bring your Medicare card, your current plan card, your drug list with doses, and your doctors and pharmacy. Bring any call notes, letter or ad you're unsure about, too.

What we won't do: call you without permission, show up uninvited, ask for bank or card numbers, charge a fee, or rush you. There's no cost to you for the review and no obligation to enroll.

We can meet in person in Kissimmee, by phone or by video. Learn what a no-cost Medicare review covers or see Medicare options in Kissimmee.

Frequently asked questions

Does Medicare call you about open enrollment?

Medicare won't call you uninvited to ask for personal information or to sell you a plan. If someone says they're from Medicare, hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) yourself.

How can I tell if a Medicare ad or website is fake?

Type Medicare.gov yourself instead of clicking ads. Look for "Ad" or "Sponsored" labels and the .gov ending. Be careful with government-looking logos, "everyone qualifies" money or benefits, and pressure to act today.

What is a licensed Medicare agent allowed to do?

A licensed agent can explain plan options, give you plan materials and an enrollment form, collect your completed form, and call you back if you asked them to. You decide if and when to sign.

What can't a Medicare agent or plan do?

They can't call or text you without permission, come to your home uninvited, charge an enrollment fee, ask you to pay over the phone, offer cash or gifts worth more than $15 to join, or pressure you to sign.

Why do I have to sign a form before an appointment with an agent?

Medicare requires agents to record which types of plans you agreed to discuss before a sales appointment. It limits the conversation to what you chose. It doesn't enroll you in anything.

How do I check if an insurance agent is licensed in Florida?

Use the Florida Department of Financial Services Licensee Search at LicenseeSearch.FLDFS.com. Search the agent's name or license number and make sure the license is active.

Where do I report a Medicare or health insurance scam in Florida?

Call 1-800-MEDICARE, Florida SHINE / Senior Medicare Patrol at 1-800-963-5337, and report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. For Marketplace questions, use HealthCare.gov or call 1-800-318-2596.

A second set of eyes, at no cost

Want a second opinion on a call, mailer or ad you got? Bring it to a no-cost Medicare review: https://www.ltkinsurance.com/book, or call (863) 563-4209. There's no cost to you for the review and no obligation to enroll.

Ryan Goulding, licensed in Florida (FL License #G304148 · NPN 17090608)

We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 10 organizations which offer 30 products in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page